7 Mistakes That Get Even Legal Immigrants Deported (Number 4 Shocked Me)

by

Navigating the U.S. immigration system is difficult enough — but what many people don’t realize is that even legal immigrants can face deportation for mistakes they never knew were serious.

From minor paperwork oversights to everyday misunderstandings of immigration rules, these pitfalls can put lawful status at risk without warning.

In this guide, we break down the 7 most common mistakes that get even legal immigrants deported — and number 4 surprised even us. Understanding these risks is essential to protecting your future in the United States.

Mistake #1 Crimes of Moral Turpitude

Certain offenses—known as crimes involving moral turpitude—carry especially harsh consequences, including deportation, even for green card holders.

These crimes typically involve conduct considered dishonest, deceptive, or morally unacceptable, such as fraud, theft, domestic violence, or certain assault-related offenses.

What complicates things further is that even a single conviction could trigger removal proceedings for permanent residents and nonimmigrant visa holders.

Example: A green card holder from Mexico was convicted of theft involving more than $1,000. Because this crime of moral turpitude occurred within five years of his admission as a permanent resident, he became deportable — even though his sentence was only probation.

This case illustrates that even minor cases can have major immigration consequences.

Mistake #2 Being Convicted of an Aggravated Felony

Under immigration law, “aggravated felony” is a term that covers a wide range of offenses, many of which don’t sound serious based on their name alone.

Crimes like drug trafficking, burglary, sexual abuse crimes, and even some assault or firearm-related convictions can fall into this category.

A single aggravated felony conviction can lead to mandatory deportation with virtually no opportunity for relief, even for longtime green card holders with deep family and community ties.

What makes this especially dangerous is that some offenses are labeled “aggravated felonies” under immigration law even when they’re treated as lower-level crimes in criminal court.

Example: A long-time green card holder from Jamaica was convicted of selling just $150 worth of cocaine to an undercover officer. Under immigration law, any drug-trafficking offense — no matter how small the amount — is considered an aggravated felony. As a result, he is barred from relief and faces mandatory deportation.

Warning: Before accepting any plea deal, always speak with an immigration attorney to understand whether the conviction could be classified as an aggravated felony under federal immigration laws.

Mistake #3 Controlled Substance Violations

Nearly any controlled substance conviction, whether for possession, use, or paraphernalia, can trigger removal proceedings. While there is a narrow exception for a single offense involving a small amount of marijuana for personal use, most drug violations offer no forgiveness under immigration law. What surprises many people is that even admitting to drug use — without a conviction — can create immigration problems during applications or interviews.

It does not matter if the conviction is old or if it was handled through a deferred adjudication — immigration law still treats it as a controlled substance violation.

Example: A Canadian green card holder had a 2009 misdemeanor conviction in the state of California for possessing 35 grams of marijuana. Even though the case was expunged, years later when he applied for U.S. citizenship, Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) uncovered the old conviction and placed him in removal proceedings.

Warning: Avoid any involvement with controlled substances and never make admissions about drug use during immigration processes without first consulting an attorney.

Mistake #4 Failing to Report an Address Change

Many immigrants don’t realize that keeping your address current with U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) isn’t optional — it’s a legal requirement.

Green card holders and visa holders must report any change of address within 10 days of moving.

Failing to do so, even unintentionally, can lead to penalties, detainment, or even removal proceedings if USCIS believes you are trying to hide your location. This seemingly minor administrative step has led to deportation cases that shock many immigrants, especially those who thought such errors were harmless.

Always update your address with USCIS promptly and keep proof of submission to avoid serious consequences.

Mistake #5 Committing Document Fraud

Using false documents or misrepresenting information on immigration forms is one of the fastest ways to put your legal status at risk. This includes everything from submitting fake IDs, altered visas, or forged employment records to lying on applications for green cards or citizenship.

Immigration authorities take fraud extremely seriously. Even a single misrepresentation, intentional or not, can result in removal proceedings and a permanent bar from reentry. Many immigrants underestimate how broad the definition of “fraud” is under U.S. immigration law, which can include omissions or misleading statements.

Example: A long-time green card holder originally from the Philippines submitted a fake divorce decree to qualify for his green card. Years later, when he applied for naturalization, ICE discovered the fraud during the background check. Since he had never been divorced, this misrepresentation became grounds for removal proceedings.

Warning: Always provide truthful, complete information on all immigration forms and never attempt to submit fraudulent documents.

Mistake #6 Overstaying or Violating your Visa

Another way legal immigrants get into trouble is by overstaying their visa or violating its terms. Even a few days past your authorized stay can trigger serious consequences, including being barred from reentry for years or facing removal proceedings.

Visa violations aren’t limited to overstaying—they also include working without authorization, studying when only tourist status is permitted, or failing to maintain required status.

Many immigrants assume minor infractions won’t matter, but U.S. immigration law treats these violations very seriously, and they can have long-lasting effects on future applications.

Example: A student from Brazil held an F-1 visa, which required him to maintain full-time enrollment. While attending school, he worked part-time and later dropped some classes, affecting his SEVIS record. When he attempted to re-enter the U.S. after a vacation, CBP discovered the violations, canceled his student visa at the port of entry, and sent him back to Brazil.

Always track your visa expiration date, understand the conditions of your status, and seek guidance before taking any actions that could affect your legal status.

Mistake #7 Domestic Violence or Firearms Offenses

Convictions for domestic violence, stalking, child abuse, or certain firearm-related crimes can make a legal immigrant deportable. Immigration law treats these offenses very seriously because they are seen as threats to public safety. Even if the sentence is short or the individual is a long-time green card holder, these convictions can trigger removal proceedings and make it difficult to obtain future immigration benefits.

Example: A green card holder from El Salvador was convicted of domestic battery after striking his wife during an argument. Although it was only a misdemeanor under state law, immigration authorities classified it as a domestic violence offense, making him deportable with no possibility of relief.

Warning: Avoid any criminal conduct involving domestic violence or firearms offenses and seek immediate guidance from an immigration attorney if charged with such offenses.

Conclusion

Even lawful immigrants are not immune to deportation if they overlook legal obligations. Staying informed and acting responsibly can make all the difference in preserving your immigration status.

Contact Us. If you would like to schedule a consultation, please text 619-483-4549 or call 619-819-9204.

Helpful Links

JOIN OUR NEW FACEBOOK GROUP

Need more immigration updates? We have created a new facebook group to address the impact of the new executive orders and other changing developments. Follow us there!